She speaks far too much. I would have her panties down as soon as her red marks subsided. Then a further and harder caning....for speaking during a formal Wife Beating.
This rug beater seems to be effective. I usually use a leather paddle, leather riding crop or a cane. I think I will buy one soon and test it on the back side of my sub.
I disagree. He is a poor spanker..Her angle is all wrong. The panties ought to be down, and across two pillows to raise the bottom. Her cunny is not on view, thus he misses the humiliating aspect. He ought to punish EVERY attempt at escape. A VERY poor performance.